Review: Rogue One: A Star Wars Story


The ending to this story has been known for nearly forty years. Where can we find suspense in a narrative to which we already know the outcome? In some ways, the theft of the Death Star plans and the battle station’s eventual destruction are as pivotal a moment in the Star Wars narrative as Pearl Harbor was to America. The big picture facts of both events are plain and clear, but the individuals involved in those battles are the stories worth exploring. Rogue One: A Star Wars Story provides the franchise with an in the trenches account of the desperate mission, using an almost entirely fresh ensemble that does well enough to show how despair transforms into hope.

As the first of Lucasfilm’s stand alone Star Wars adventures, Rogue One throws us right into space, sans title crawl, with a prologue involving Imperial Director Orson Krennic (Ben Mendelsohn) arriving at the farming homestead of scientist Galen Erso (Mads Mikkelsen). Both men had once worked on the Death Star project together, and Krennic has been tasked to bring back Erso to do more scientific work for its completion. Knowing his family is in danger, Galen urges them to flee, but the situation quickly turns tragic. Erso’s little girl manages to escape, and is eventually rescued by family friend and Rebel extremist Saw Garrera (Forest Whitaker).

The film then jumps years later, and it begins setting up several of the key players who will eventually form the Rogue One team. We meet Captain Cassian Andor (Diego Luna), a Rebel intelligence officer and his reprogrammed Imperial droid, K-2SO (Alan Tudyk), who receive information concerning the whereabouts of Galen. The intel comes from a defecting Imperial pilot named Bodhi Rook (Riz Ahmed), but he’s currently in the custody of Saw Garrera, whose relationship to the Rebel Alliance is tenuous at best. Cassian manages to track down Jyn Erso (Felicity Jones), now an adult and deeply skeptical of the Rebel cause. With the influence of the Rebel leadership, Jyn realizes that finding Bodhi Rook could lead to her father, and in turn, provide the Alliance with the weakness to the Empire’s terrifying new weapon.

Structurally, Rogue One really rushes to establish itself and set up all of its characters in the first act, so much so that the flow of information can be difficult to follow. The opening prologue in particular has some striking visual moments in it, yet the editing is so haphazard that the emotional impact feels stunted. Some streamlining could have improved other expository scenes as well, as the film hops across at least four planets in the span of twenty minutes. Once the mission kicks into gear, however, the film settles into its own groove. As the crew grows in size and the stakes of their mission increase, the overly anxious pacing eventually translates into genuine urgency.

One of the biggest challenges of Rogue One is that its core ensemble is made up of brand new characters, all of whom must earn the investment of the audience. While there are an abundance of cameos, Rogue One does not have the luxury of leaning upon familiar characters. In this test, Rogue One mostly passes, in that many of the new characters are likable and well defined, but it only rarely lends itself to full emotional investment as the stakes grow. Jyn Erso is another strong independent woman in the tradition of Star Wars female protagonists, but Felicity Jones’ performance doesn’t fully click until about halfway through the film at a critical emotional juncture. While Mads Mikkelsen’s presence in the film is fairly minimal, he also carries the film’s most resonant line, one that spurs his daughter into action. Saw Garrera falls on the morally grey spectrum of characters whose justifications go beyond allegiance to any single party. Forest Whitaker is ideal for the role, and gives Garrera a crazed personality that has spawned from decades of battling oppression. Diego Luna does solid work as Cassian Andor, who must also wrestle with his own moral compass at times, and also confront Jyn in times of intense hardship. K-2SO is the clear element of comic relief in the film, and Alan Tudyk’s timing rivals some of the best one liners among the Star Wars films. Bodhi Rook is one of the most important components of the Rogue One crew, and Riz Ahmed imbues him with a nervous energy throughout, always cognizant of what the consequences might be of every decision he makes. On the planet of Jedha, the crew runs into two refugees who operate on opposite ends of the spiritual spectrum. Though he is not a Jedi, the blind warrior monk Chirrut Imwe (Donnie Yen) intuits the Force in combating his enemies, while his friend Baze Malbus (Jiang Wen) relies on his formidable artillery to do the talking. Rogue One touches somewhat on the idea of the Force existing beyond the familiar practices, yet it also resists investigating the other ways it might manifest itself. To round out the core cast, every group of Rebels needs a menacing foe, and at the start, Ben Mendelson’s Director Krennic fits the bill. His encounter with Galen at the film’s start oozes charisma and sliminess, but as the film progresses, Krennic finds himself at the mercy of his superiors.

Consider this paragraph a spoiler warning, as the discussion turns to the various cameos in the film. Several key members of the Rebel Alliance play minor supporting roles in Rogue One, and while their presence is brief, seeing faces like those of Mon Mothma and Bail Organa provide added weight to the proceedings, especially knowing the latter’s eventual fate. However, other cameos feel like full on fan service and are frankly unnecessary, particularly Jyn’s brief run in with the Mos Eisley cantina denizens who give Luke Skywalker a rough time in A New Hope. Perhaps even more controversial is the resurrection of two major players from that film. Indeed, thanks to advances in CGI and motion capture, ILM has managed to resurrect Peter Cushing as Grand Moff Tarkin. It’s an astonishing accomplishment, aside from the fact that the digital double’s mobility is looser than the original rigid and calculating performance by Cushing. Even more surreal is seeing a young Carrie Fisher as Princess Leia in a single shot, as she utters an inevitably obvious line to fully connect Rogue One to A New Hope. And of course, the Dark Lord of the Sith himself makes an appearance in the film. Yes, Darth Vader is as fearsome a figure as ever, and in his brief screen time, director Gareth Edwards makes the most of two opportunities that add to the mystique and terror of the greatest of all cinematic villains. And yet, the contexts of those scenes feel unnecessary for Rogue One, and to a lesser extent, perhaps excessive to Vader himself. His effect on the film threatens to steal the thunder of the story we should be following.

Director Gareth Edwards is no stranger to spectacle on screen, but Rogue One delivers some of the largest scale sequences that Star Wars has seen. The aforementioned planet hopping may be too erratic at times, but new worlds like Jedha and the tropical Imperial outpost of Scarif add to the size and dimension of the galaxy. With the influence of war films throughout, Rogue One is also one of the most action packed Star Wars films, changing from close quarters street combat, space battles, and ground assault. Some of these earlier action beats are harder to follow because of the prevalence of handheld photography and over reliance on editing, but the film’s third act is often outstanding in its execution. If there’s one major element that Rogue One seems to be lacking in, it is the score. Naturally, a new Star Wars film on an annual basis is far too much for John Williams to keep pace with, and Michael Giacchino is a highly capable composer, considering he was hired as a replacement only four months ago. Ultimately, the music rarely carries the story in the same way it does in other Star Wars films, engaging at best and perfunctory at worst.

Ultimately, a film like Rogue One demonstrates the trajectory for what Lucasfilm and Disney may want to do with their most valued franchise. Two films in, there’s been a delicate line balanced between taking risks, and falling back on reliable safety nets. Rogue One goes out on a limb with its characters’ trajectories and thematic investigations in the thorny relationships that build loyalty and unification, and yet it never quite arrives at moments that define Star Wars at its transcendent best. Nevertheless, what is most exciting about Lucasfilm in contrast to so many other franchise shepherds is that it is always in search of new and exciting filmmakers to put their own stamps on these stories. As long as these voices are continually welcomed into the fold, then this galaxy will always be worth exploring.


~ by romancinema on December 16, 2016.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: